Significantly absent in the long obituaries for Pope Francis in both the New York Times and the Washington Post were mentions of his deep concern for the suffering of the Palestinian people in Gaza. In Francis’s last public message on Easter Sunday, just hours before he died, he had called for a ceasefire in Gaza, and condemned the “deplorable humanitarian situation” there.
The obits also failed to note that Pope Francis had personally telephoned the Holy Family Church in Gaza just about every evening since Israel invaded the territory in October 2023–including the Saturday night before Easter. The church’s pastor, Rev. Gabriel Romanelli, remembered: “He said he was praying for us, he blessed us, and he thanked us for our prayers.” Other church members said that the Pope “would make sure to speak not only to the priest but to everyone else in the room.”
Pope Francis’s concern for Gaza and Palestine did not start in October 2023. Rev. Munther Isaac, a Palestinian Christian theologian and Lutheran pastor, told Democracy Now:
I think no Palestinian will ever forget when Pope Francis, in 2014, stopped his car, went down, stepped down and prayed at the separation wall separating Jerusalem from Bethlehem–a moment that touched all of us and continued to speak to us for years.
Of course, there was plenty in the life of this remarkable 88-year-old man to include in those obituaries. But the pontiff’s ongoing concern for Gaza surely should have been part of the record in America’s leading newspapers. Those nightly telephone calls were exactly the kind of detail that brings a story to life. Instead, part of Pope Francis’s message is being erased.
So what actually happened at the New York Times? Journalists with first-hand experience there have told me that 95 percent of the self-censorship about Israel/Palestine is unspoken. “No one has to actually tell you to skirt the subject,” one source explained.
You just understand that you have to be very careful.
Free speech is under attack—especially when it comes to Palestine.
From the censorship of student voices to the assassinations of journalists in Gaza, the cost of telling the truth about Palestine has never been higher. At Mondoweiss, we publish fearless reporting and critical analysis that others won’t touch—because we believe the public needs to know the truth about Palestine.
We’re funded by readers who believe in justice, transparency, and freedom of the press.
James North is a Mondoweiss’ Editor-at-Large, and has reported from Africa, Latin America, and Asia for four decades. He lives in New York City.