| April Pipkins left holds a picture of her son Emantic Bradford Jr Bob Dole right salutes the casket of President George H W Bush Photo Jay ReevesDrew Angerer AP ImagesGetty Images | MR Online April Pipkins (left) holds a picture of her son Emantic Bradford Jr. Bob Dole (right) salutes the casket of President George H. W. Bush Photo: Jay Reeves/Drew Angerer (AP Images/Getty Images)

‘Civility’ is for white people

Originally published: The Root on December 5, 2018 by Michael Harriot (more by The Root)  | (Posted Dec 07, 2018)

We should not speak ill of the dead.

Even if the truth is unsavory, the dead deserve our condolences and respect. We must be civil. Especially if they are white.

Last night, just before I dozed off, I caught the first few minutes of SportsCenter with Scott Van Pelt (who actually hosts the best version of the show since ESPN got rid of Jemele Hill and Michael Smith’s 6 p.m. version). Each night, Van Pelt opens the show with “SVP’s Best Thing,” which is the best thing he saw during that day.

On Tuesday’s show, he replayed the moving clip of Bob Dole saluting the casket of former president George H.W. Bush. Dole had come to Washington to pay his respects for a National Day of Mourning. Van Pelt heralded Dole’s tribute and mentioned how it reminded him that civility, respect, and honor still matter.

As Van Pelt opined about how this particular corpse highlighted the need for reverence and unity in America, protesters in Alabama were shutting down a busy interstate exit ramp in Hoover. Before stopping in the middle of the interstate, backing up traffic for miles as if they were part of a presidential motorcade, the protesters had already marched inside a local Wal Mart and a Buffalo Wild Wings for their own day of mourning.

The protesters were demanding justice and transparency for the death of Emantic “E.J.” Bradford Jr., who was killed by a Hoover police officer on November 22. Since the incident, demonstrators vowed that the idyllic Birmingham suburb will not have peace until justice has been served.

The good white people of Hoover, meanwhile, lobbed racist invectives at the protesters in person and on social media because, according to them, Hoover doesn’t “deserve this.”


So much for civility, honor and respect for the dead.

Although many people are angry about the whitewashing of George H.W. Bush’s legacy, I did not find him particularly evil. Considering how Ronald Reagan has become a Republican hero in death and George W. Bush has been whitewashed into an affable Muppet who once ran this great land after stealing the presidency, I can’t say I am surprised that Bush Sr. is being remembered as a hero and a statesman.

He fucked the whole AIDS thing up, but he didn’t demonize the disease as much as Reagan did. He ramped up the War on Drugs, but not as much as Clinton did. In fact, my favorite memory of George Bush is when he ordered a drug buy outside the White House and sent a black teenager to prison so he could pull out a bag of crack from his presidential desk on national TV.

No, George Bush was not particularly evil. He was just regular-strength evil.

And a hero.

And a statesman.

Because he was white.

Although I rarely marvel at white people, sometimes I stand in awe of whoever runs the wypipo public relations team. They are nothing if not bold and unashamed. They have the ability to turn on a dime and convolute the truth until it is unrecognizable.

They will hang the black president in effigy and question his legitimacy but turn around and ask that you respect and honor a virulently racist half-moron because he is the president of the “greatest country in the world.” They will say Trump is “pushing back” against his detractors when he calls Maxine Waters a “low IQ individual” but will warn me that I should refrain from calling the President a “white supremacist.

When Trump lies, they will say, for civility’s sake, that it is “inaccurate.” When he insults majority-black countries, they will call it “demeaning.” They will print the word “shithole” before they dishonor the presidency by calling him a racist or a liar.

Few have mentioned how George Bush went on TV and demonized public housing projects as crack dens, even though 74 percent of the drug violence were caused by drug laws, not drugs. Crack was no different than cocaine. The “crack babies” epidemic was a myth. Most crack users were white.

But we are supposed to honor and respect a liar because… civility.

Yet, when it comes to dead black bodies, there are no calls for reverence and dignity.

Hours after he was killed by Darren Wilson, they stripped Michael Brown of his decency by painting him as a strong-arm robber. News outlets ran the worst photos of Trayvon Martin they could find while showing George Zimmerman’s bruised face. Korryn Gaines was painted as a suicidal maniac.

And in Hoover, less than an hour after he was killed, police told the national media that E. J. Bradford was a violent criminal who opened fire in a crowded mall. They did not give a damn about an investigation when they assassinated his character and desecrated his memory.

But the protesters are supposed to wait for the investigation. They should remain civil. They should honor the legal process.

The reason the protesters have chosen to disrupt the lives of regular Hooverites is because of the “legal process.” The legal process allows police to disproportionately kill black people without fear of punishment. The legal process does not serve black people. It protects the residents of Hoover while snuffing out black lives like the end of the meaningless candlelight vigils they would have us attend instead.

Protest is supposed to be uncomfortable. I imagine there were agitated white people who just wanted to take the bus to their grandmothers’ house during the Freedom Rides. I bet there were people who just wanted lunch at the local diner during the sit in. As Alabama state troopers fractured John Lewis’ skull, I bet he was called undignified for blocking traffic. Just before Bull Connor turned Klansmen, dogs and fire hoses loose on children in Birmingham, I bet they called those kids “disrespectful.”

But we remained civilly disobedient.

Furthermore, I am willing to bet my life savings that somewhere, right now, there is a black mother or father wondering if their child will make it home safely. After the evening of November 22, April Pipkins and Emantic Bradford Jr. no longer had to wonder.

They, like countless other black parents, found out the answer was “no.”

Now that is the most uncivil thing of all

Monthly Review does not necessarily adhere to all of the views conveyed in articles republished at MR Online. Our goal is to share a variety of left perspectives that we think our readers will find interesting or useful. —Eds.