The Labor Department reported that the economy added 103,000 jobs in September. This increase, together with upward revisions to the prior two months’ data brought average job growth over the last three months to 99,000 per month, almost exactly the number needed to keep pace with the growth of the labor force. Consistent with this rate of job growth, the unemployment rate was unchanged at 9.1 percent. It has been at virtually the same level since April. The employment-to-population (EPOP) ratio did edge up slightly to 58.3 percent. This is up from a low of 58.1 percent in July, but still below the 58.5 percent level of a year ago.
The only two sectors showing much strength in September were employment services (temp help), which added 23,800 jobs, and health care, which added 43,800 jobs. Often growth in employment services is seen as a sign of permanent employment in the future, as companies often hire temps before turning to full-time employment. However, this growth only looks good in the context of a very weak labor market. Jobs in this sector grew at a rate of 48,000 a month between September of 2009 and January of 2010 without setting off any subsequent boom in full-time hires. Temp employment is still down by roughly 20 percent from its pre-recession level.
The health care numbers are striking because this seems to be part of an ongoing trend. Health care employment has grown at a rate of 31,400 per month since June, accounting for almost one-third of employment growth over this period. In a very weak labor market, health care jobs are becoming ever more important.
The one other notable bright spot was construction, which added 26,000 jobs, almost all in non-residential construction. The monthly numbers are always somewhat erratic, and this uptick could be in part attributable to repairs from the hurricanes. It is unlikely that anywhere near this pace of increase will be sustained.
Retail trade added 13,300 jobs, almost exactly its average over the last three months. Restaurants added 12,000 jobs, a small increase above the average for the last three months. The public sector lost another 34,000 jobs, almost all of it at the state and local level. This brought the average decline over the last three months to 22,000, just about the same as the rate of job loss over the last year.
The one modest bright spot in the household data was a slight improvement in the situation of African Americans. Their overall EPOP rose by 0.9 percentage points to 52.1 percent, while their unemployment rate fell by 0.7 percentage points to 16.0 percent. Both numbers are erratic, but this is the highest EPOP for African Americans since February.
The report showed a jump of 342,000 in the number of people employed involuntarily part-time, the second consecutive month with a large increase. This pushed the U6 measure (workers marginally attached to the labor force, such as discouraged workers or part-time workers who cannot find full-time employment) of unemployment to 16.5 percent, the highest since last December.
The duration measures suggest that long-term unemployment is becoming more of a problem with the average duration rising to 40.5 weeks, a new record. The share of long-term unemployed rose to 44.6 percent, which is slightly below the peaks hit earlier this year.
Older workers continue to get a disproportionate share of the jobs, with employment among workers over the age of 55 accounting for 270,000 of the 398,000 increase in employment in September. Employment among people in the over-age-55 group has risen by 972,000 over the last year (708,000 for men), while total employment in the household survey increased by only 647,000. The big losers were the 35-44 age group with a drop in employment of 485,000 (1.6 percent) and the 45-54 age group with a decline of 398,000 (1.2 percent).
Wages have risen at a 2.1 percent rate over the last three months, essentially the same as the 1.9 percent rate over the last year. On the whole, this report gives no real cause for optimism. The economy continues to grow at a very slow rate. The double-dippers have little basis for their doom-saying. However, we are making no progress in bringing the economy back to full employment.
Dean Baker is co-director of the Center for Economic and Policy Research in Washington, D.C. He is the author of several books, including False Profits: Recovering from the Bubble Economy. This article was first published by CEPR on 7 October 2011 under a Creative Commons license.